1 customer review
Read reviews →

Rated 5.0 out of 5 by verified customers.

5.0 · 1 review
1,924 sales · 538 customer reviews across Etsy and our Shopify store
Our Shopify store is new, but By The Sea SXM isn’t — these totals include our 3 years of Etsy history.

Mystery Sea Glass Gift Bag, Caribbean Treasures, Handmade Jewelry

$19.90
≈ Genuine Caribbean sea glass
Found by us beneath the waters of Saint Martin
Select your theme

Enter your personalization exactly as you would like it to appear. Examples: name, date, initials, short message, etc.

In stock

Checking Favorites...

Sign in to save Favorites to your account
Handmade Created by Rhonda & Nico
Authentic Genuine Caribbean sea glass
One of a kind Nature makes every piece different
FOUND BENEATH THE CARIBBEAN

Every piece begins with something the sea left behind.

THE STORY OF THIS PIECE

Want to take a chance? 🐚
We’ve created surprise sea glass grab bags filled with treasures from our boutique—each one unique, handmade, and full of beachy vibes.

Each kraft bag includes at least 3 handcrafted items, with a total retail value of $35 or more. You might find:
🌿 Sea glass rings
🌿 Bracelets or pendants
🌿 Worry stones, bookmarks, or earrings (sea glass or petal style)
🌿 Ornaments and more!

As a bonus, every bag includes a laser-engraved wooden ornament/gift tag:
🩵 A sea turtle that says “Keep Going” —or—
🎄 A seasonal holiday tag with cheerful messages (Fa La La, Joy to the World, etc.)

Each item was made using sea glass hand collected in the Caribbean and assembled with love in our eco-friendly studio.

📸 Sample photos show the types of items you may receive—but the fun is in the surprise!
🎁 Perfect for gifting, stocking stuffers, or treating yourself to something beachy and unexpected.

🔁 No returns or exchanges on grab bags—just enjoy the mystery!

CUSTOMER LOVE

Reviews for this item

5.0
1 review
★★★★★

“I treated myself to a mystery Xmas bag and I was so happy to see what I received Such beautiful sea glass items I’ll truly cherish”

Cheryl Pauciello 2026-11-12

Reviews originally shared by verified customers of By The Sea SXM.